-
Six autos competed for Motor Authority Finest Automotive To Purchase 2025, 5 of them EVs
-
5 of the opponents are thought-about crossovers or SUVs
-
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 N was essentially the most enjoyable to drive of the group
The transition from internal-combustion to electrical energy continued at a slower tempo than anticipated this yr, however you wouldn’t be capable of inform it from our checklist of Motor Authority Finest Automotive To Purchase 2025 candidates. 5 of the six contenders had electrical energy, although that might flip subsequent yr.
The reason being this previous yr noticed the discharge of quite a few electric-powered luxurious and efficiency autos. They included the primary electrical SUVs from Porsche and Acura, a performance-oriented crossover from Hyundai, an electrical ultra-luxury off-roader from Mercedes, and a considerable replace for probably the greatest electrical SUVs we’ve ever pushed—from the startup Rivian.
They had been joined by a performance-oriented, gas-powered coupe from Mercedes, although much more efficiency is actually within the offing in 2025 within the type of a 63 mannequin.
Our testing this yr concerned our first drive experiences for all of the autos, monitor testing at Atlanta Motorsports Park, and road driving on the twisty roads of rural northern Georgia. Certain, no less than three of the autos appeared like fish out of water on the monitor, however that testing revealed dynamic qualities that impressed greater than anticipated.
Observe functionality isn’t the lone qualification to earn the Motor Authority Finest Automotive To Purchase award. We additionally search for engagement, luxurious, enjoyable issue, on-road livability, and even worth. Pushing the envelope for luxurious or efficiency can even assist, and our winner, the Hyundai Ioniq 5 N did simply that as the primary actually sporty crossover EV available on the market.
Under, we break down how every of our contenders carried out in our testing. We word their strengths and weaknesses, share insights from our editors on their dynamics, and clarify why they did or didn’t win.
2024 Acura ZDX Kind S
2024 Acura ZDX Kind S
2024 Acura ZDX Kind S
Acura ZDX Kind S
Acura doesn’t do a lot to distinguish the ZDX Kind S from the step-down A-Spec mannequin. It has simply 9 extra hp for a complete of 499 hp, although torque will increase significantly from 437 to 544 lb-ft. It additionally will get larger brakes, adaptive dampers and air springs with firmer suspension tuning, barely faster steering, and greater wheels and tires. At 6,052 kilos, that’s not precisely the components for a monitor machine.
So, the Acura ZDX Kind S was out of its aspect on the monitor at AMP, however it did effectively in some methods in comparison with the Mercedes G 580 Electrical and Rivian R1S. Amongst these SUVs, it sits the bottom to the bottom and that makes it extra nimble on turn-in and usually mid-corner. It had the perfect, quickest steering and response among the many three, with some spectacular quick turn-in. “Raise-off-oversteer is an actual factor with this automobile,” Senior Producer Joel Feder famous. That turned out to be a very good technique to get by way of flip 4’s 180-degree lefthander. Nevertheless, that technique made it arduous to take care of a constant line within the huge turn-7-8-9 carousel. Senior Editor Bengt Halvorson felt it didn’t have the physique management he anticipated, and Editorial Director Marty Padgett mentioned that the ZDX doesn’t come throughout as a extra succesful model of what’s already obtainable available on the market.
We additionally felt little confidence within the brakes; its 102-mph prime velocity heading into flip 1 may have risen to 110 mph or so with stronger binders. We did see 108 mph later, however our trepidation proved prescient as we overheated the brakes at that velocity, inflicting the ZDX to enter limp mode. The 275/40R22 Michelin Primacy All Season tires held up higher than another summer time tires on aggressive EVs, although they couldn’t match these tires for grip.
In fact, the monitor character holds little worth for ZDX patrons, as vanishingly few, if any, will take it on a monitor. On the highway, it’s comfy and highly effective. Nevertheless, we see little cause Acura can cost extra for the ZDX than Cadillac expenses for the associated Lyriq, and each Feder and Padgett mentioned they’d take the Lyriq’s typical springs and coils versus Acura’s air suspension. Padgett additionally mentioned that he’s all the time related Acura with a extra succesful model of what’s on the market in any other case, however to him, “this Acura’s a transparent product stopgap, one with an un-Acura-like flying carpet journey.”
2025 Mercedes-Benz G 580 with EQ Know-how
2025 Mercedes-Benz G 580 with EQ Know-how
2025 Mercedes-Benz G 580 with EQ Know-how
Mercedes-Benz AMG G 580 with EQ Know-how
You don’t ask an offensive lineman to carry out “Swan Lake.” You don’t compete with a semi tractor in an autocross. And also you don’t take an electrical G-Class on a racetrack, however that’s precisely what we did. Predictably, the AMG G 580 with EQ Know-how proved itself a flop machine that must be wrangled by way of every nook, the place we skilled copious physique lean even in Sport mode. Its Falken Azenis FR520 275/50R20 tires had little grip, and it was the slowest automobile within the carousel apex. Initially, we had been solely comfy with taking this flip at 65 mph, however once we discovered a strategy to higher straight-line the apex we bought it as much as 72 mph. Senior Editor Robert Duffer referred to as it a Weeble, however famous that it had “sufficient squish within the carousel to take a set.” Halvorson agreed, saying “inserting a heavy battery pack low on this tall, boxy automobile has a stabilizing impact.” Feder bought a bit of extra technical: “The 4-motor powertrain asserts instantaneous management of every wheel, whether or not it’s going round flip 6 on AMP or climbing a slick-rock formation off-road.” That provides this beast wonderful off-road functionality and a shocking skill to not embarrass itself on the monitor.
With 6,746 kilos to inspire, the G 580 was additionally the slowest automobile on the straight at 98 mph. That wasn’t as a result of an absence of energy, although, because the G 580’s quad motors spin up 579 hp and 859 lb-ft of torque. As a substitute, it was as a result of we had been uncomfortable transferring all that weight in flip 16 main into the entrance straight or trusting the brakes to decelerate such a tall, heavy beast.
A monitor was not the venue for this beast, because it’s constructed as a fairly charming off-roader. Padgett referred to as it a “meme-worthy extremist, one with an ideal sense of self-deprecating humor,” noting that with the push of a button to activate its G Flip function, it could spin in place.
The electrical G 580 begins at a staggering $162,650, and our tester had $28,000 in choices, all of which had been both aesthetic or consolation options. At that worth, you need to respect the electrical G 580’s celebration methods in addition to its luxurious bona fides, however you don’t should name it a Finest Automotive To Purchase winner.
2025 Rivian R1S
2025 Rivian R1S
2025 Rivian R1S
Rivian R1S Tri-Max Ascend
The revised Rivian R1S doesn’t sit as little as the ZDX, however it had essentially the most succesful dealing with of the large SUVs on the monitor. That’s as a result of its superior suspension that mixes an air suspension with linked-hydraulic dampers developed by McLaren. Collectively they do a tremendous job of counteracting physique lean. Feder referred to as it magic, and famous he was in a position to push it to 76 mph within the carousel apex regardless of a fairly non-sticky set of Pirelli Scorpion MS HL275/50R22 tires. Among the many SUVs, the R1S was essentially the most secure in corners because it maintained a constant line throttle on or throttle off. “Rivian didn’t construct this off-road SUV for the monitor, but it’s composed and doesn’t collapse. It doesn’t really feel prime heavy. The whole factor takes a line and simply vegetation itself,” Feder defined.
With its tri-motor powertrain, the R1S was simply essentially the most highly effective of all our contenders. Its trio of motors spins out 850 hp and 1,103 lb-ft of torque, which unlocks a 3.0-second 0-60 mph time. Any time we bought arduous on the throttle, the R1S responded with a right away rush of energy, and the a number of motors aided dealing with. “With the 2 rear motors controlling torque at both rear wheel, you may come out of it with wonderful grip,” Duffer famous. The large 6,846-pound SUV hit 110 mph on the entrance straight. Nevertheless, it had the worst brake really feel, with a spongy pedal, an inconsistent chew level, and lengthy pedal journey. The brakes improved a bit as soon as we drained the battery as that allowed the R1S to include extra regenerative braking. Had we been extra assured within the brakes, the R1S might have hit 120 mph, however as Duffer mentioned, “you may solely go as quick as you may brake.”
Total, the R1S is a tremendous achievement in efficiency for such an enormous, heavy automobile with a number of off-road functionality. Nevertheless, it may enhance with higher brakes, and maybe a special brake tune with a full battery. We’re followers, a lot in order that no less than two of us have considered shopping for one. “Would I want the Hyundai or Porsche to drive out right here (on the monitor)? On a regular basis. Would I spec the R1S for my very own lifetime day by day driver? I imply, I have already got, a number of occasions,” mentioned Padgett.
2024 Mercedes-Benz AMG CLE 53
2024 Mercedes-Benz AMG CLE 53
2024 Mercedes-Benz AMG CLE 53
Mercedes-Benz AMG CLE 53 4Matic
Our lone gasoline contender had the benefit of weight. That’s to not say at 4,420 kilos the AMG CLE 53 4Matic is mild, however at 400-2,300 kilos lighter than the others it was in a position to construct comparatively extra velocity within the entrance straight given its energy output. It was additionally the least highly effective entry, as its twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter inline-6 makes “simply” 443 hp and 413 lb-ft, the latter of which might rise to 443 lb-ft in 10-second overboost bursts. Nonetheless, we had been in a position to push it to 115 mph on the entrance straight, aided by the power to hold extra velocity into flip 16 and extra confidence when braking into flip 1. There’s extra room for energy, as Feder referred to as it “fast sufficient, not quick.” All of us agreed that the CLE 53 made the perfect sounds, with a robust burble at idle and a roar below acceleration, however when the competitors is all artificial, that’s not saying a lot.
It additionally carried 81 mph by way of the carousel apex. Whereas that wasn’t the quickest of the day, it was spectacular given the tender tune of the CLE 53’s suspension. “The extraordinarily tender suspension setup leaves far an excessive amount of room for a steel-suspension CLE 63 to return,” noticed Padgett. “This one’s in WRX territory: softened up so the precise patrons will find it irresistible greater than the trackhounds who flog it mercilessly, out of context, on a monitor like this one.” Halvorson agreed, saying the automobile was “altogether let down by suspension and chassis controls that permit this coupe to really feel wobbly within the corners.”
The CLE 53 had different dynamic benefits, together with sturdy grip from the Michelin Pilot Sport S 5 tires, nice brakes, and properly weighted, exact steering.
Add these strengths to a automobile with extra energy and a sharper tune, and also you’d have a extremely sturdy contender. That’s doubtless coming within the type of a CLE 63. “The tender suspension and lack of fireside and fury simply made me desire a CLE 63 that hasn’t been launched but,” opined Feder.
2024 Porsche Macan Electrical Turbo
2024 Porsche Macan Electrical Turbo
2024 Porsche Macan EV
Porsche Macan Turbo Electrical
Porsche is gonna Porsche. If the German luxurious model develops it, you may guess it’s going to be sporty. Porsche already made a high-performance EV within the type of the Taycan hatchback and wagon, and now it’s the crossover SUV’s flip. Regardless of its change from gasoline to electrical energy, the brand new Macan Electrical looks like a next-generation Macan. “Solely Porsche might be so constant in highway really feel with this automobile to the gasoline Macan, a lot so it blurs the road for anybody undecided between the duo,” noticed Padgett.
The Macan Electrical Turbo mannequin is the highest of the lineup. It encompasses a motor on every axle that mix to create all-wheel drive and a normal 576 hp and 811 lb-ft that jumps to 630 hp and 833 lb-ft with an overboost mode that’s obtainable for 10-second spurts. They’re fed by a 95-kwh battery that gives 288 miles of vary. It additionally comes normal with air springs, adaptive dampers, an electronically managed locking rear differential, and bigger entrance brakes (14.8-inch rotors with 6-piston calipers). Our tester additionally had the non-obligatory rear-wheel steering and 255/40R22 entrance and 295/35R22 rear Pirelli P Zero Corsa summer time efficiency tires.
On the monitor, the Macan Electrical performed the hero. Sharp steering, managed physique motions, sturdy brakes, and prodigious energy had us all singing its praises. “It was exact and surgical because it carved by way of the AMP circuit. Kicking the rear finish out and sliding by way of flip 6 wasn’t a problem,” mentioned Feder. Certainly, after watching Feder drift the Macan by way of flip 6, I requested if he thought he was Vaughn Gittin Jr.
Halvorson mentioned it helped him drive higher. “On the monitor, the Porsche Macan Electrical is right down to enterprise and uncluttered, and a confidence-inspiring, prepared accomplice to assist me get the quickest lap,” he mentioned. Duffer agreed: “Every lap gave me extra confidence to push it, and every time behind the wheel on the road or the monitor felt like a deal with.” The numbers bore out our impressions: 84 mph within the carousel apex and a prime velocity of 121 mph, each highs for the day.
We did encounter a few dynamic niggles. At 5,393 kilos with a lot of that weight set low, I felt a fast weight shift with every flip of the wheel earlier than the chassis took a set. Padgett mentioned he felt a slight disconnect between journey management and steering heft, which he attributed to softened turn-in steering weight on Porsche SUVs with rear-axle steering. And we chunked the tires. “This factor peeled layers off its rubber like slices of deli meat,” quipped Padgett. The Pirellis additionally separated on the Ioniq 5 N, so it might be the tires greater than the surplus curb weight of EVs.
In our last voting it was a detailed race between the Macan Turbo Electrical and the Ioniq 5 N, however the Macan’s $107,295 beginning worth and the $130,760 sticker worth of our tester meant it simply didn’t current the worth of the Hyundai. Nonetheless, it’s an ideal automobile that we might all like to have in our garages.
2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N
2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N
2025 Hyundai Ioniq 5 N
Hyundai Ioniq 5 N
For the fanatic, sporty EVs face two main points versus their gasoline counterparts, weight and driver engagement. They make few pure sounds, don’t have any want for shifts (guide or computerized), they usually have a tendency so as to add about 1,000 kilos of unwelcome weight. Whereas the Ioniq 5 N weighs in at a fairly portly 4,861 kilos, that made it the lightest EV in our competitors, and Hyundai bakes in a variety of fakery to each simulate engagement and increase efficiency.
It really works, and adept chassis tuning and an enormous dose of energy don’t harm both. The Ioniq 5 N has entrance and rear motors to spin up 601 hp (641 hp with overboost) and 545 lb-ft. An N Grin Shift mode simulates eight gears with fast energy cuts throughout the “shifts,” and it makes the electrical powertrain act like a gasoline one. Nevertheless, Feder famous that it additionally makes the automobile slower round a monitor due to the cuts and the ability constructing because the faux revs construct. No worries. You may flip it off and get the complete electrical expertise, which is able to pushing this automobile from 0-60 mph in simply 3.3 seconds.
Each monitor session could be a completely different expertise, however they’ll all be entertaining. “The dynamics will be programmed six methods to Sunday for the motive force’s liking, and numerous setups will be saved to 2 completely different buttons on the steering wheel. That is straight BMW M-level stuff,” famous Feder. Drivers can select numerous settings for the steering, motors, stability management, suspension, limited-slip differential, and sound.
The Ioniq 5 N wasn’t fairly the quickest across the monitor, as we hit 82 mph within the carousel apex and 117 mph on the entrance straight. Nevertheless, it was essentially the most enjoyable. “It was the Ioniq 5 N that gave me essentially the most seat-of-the-pants thrills, with its open invitation to float and rotate,” enthused Halvorson. Duffer referred to as it a “playful bunny, hopping round all completely happy and keen, then getting sly and critical with hazard approaching,” whereas Padgett mentioned, “the Ioniq 5 N zings, flings, and sings (or doesn’t) alongside along with your each whim.”
We had been cut up on the faux sounds. I discovered them pleasant, and Halvorson mentioned, “the gasoline-tuner-car sounds had been so cartoonishly overdone that I couldn’t assist however grin.” Nevertheless, Padgett referred to as their mock sports activities automobile roar the equal of pec implants.
Whereas the 5 N had sturdy brakes, fast steering, and gut-dropping energy, we did discover two dynamic flaws. Within the dampers’ Sport and Sport+ settings, the hatchback exhibited some bounding motions heading down the hill into turns 9 and 10 when extra weight was over its nostril and the rear finish lightened up. And, like they did on the Macan Electrical, the Pirellis began to fray late within the day.
The enjoyable we had behind the wheel and the thought of an approachable EV monitor automobile (at $67,685) put the Ioniq 5 N excessive as our winner. Halvorson summed it up: “The Ioniq 5 N actually opens the thought of a totally electrical monitor day to a brand new era and a a lot wider go-fast crowd.”
